Please please help :(

edited December 2012 in Akita (秋田犬)
Hi everyone:
Our six month old Haru is a great lovable protector that I got for our family after the grieving period calmed for our Husky/Malamute cross (Ice), who was killed by a maniac driver when he was let out late at night off leash for a pee in our rural area. Haru has been very energetic and always a little rough at play since we got him at 8 weeks old. He has been lovingly cared for, but we have also been stern with him, so that he knows his place in the family, but he bit our six year old son on the arm about a month ago while our son was eating supper, and my wife Cindy, who was out of the room at the time, said she heard Haru, and that he sounded ferocious when he bit him. I was away at work, but we decided to keep him outside when we were eating, and give him his meals at the same time as ours. I'm away at work right now, and she called me today and told me that our son was watching TV, and Haru did the same thing again. Our son, (Willie) doesn't pick at Haru or torment him, and when we're around and out on our walking trails they're good together. Now we don't know if we can trust him with Willie, and we are very distraught. Haru is scheduled to be neutered next week, but Cindy feels that she may never be able to trust him around Willie again, and we may have to find a new home for him. Is there someone out there who can help us?
«1

Comments

  • What do you mean by "stern with him"?
  • This is something that is far beyond what we can help with you with, but what you do need to do, now is find a good behavioralist to work with. Make sure the person really is a behavioralist (not just a trainer) and find someone who does positive reinforcement work. They will be able to evaluate the dog and see how much of a threat he is to your child, and also to watch your family interactions with your dog to get a better sense of what is going on. Then, they can probably help you begin to work with your dog in a behavior modification program that will deal with aggression issues (this may well be about resource guarding, but who knows?). Behavior modification programs that work are not quick fixes--they take awhile. It will probably also not be inexpensive. But you have a problem, now, and you'll need to deal with it, and honestly, giving up a dog that has twice bitten a child is not a solution--it's just passing on a problem to someone else (though certainly, I understand your concern for your child!)

    It's also really important you find a behavioralist who does positive reinforcement....aversives and rough handling will only make this problem worse. I'm not sure what you mean by "being stern" with the dog, but I'd be very, very careful of using aversives--esp. no physical punishment--with the dog right now, as that could make it worse as well. (I would not use a physical punishment ever anyway, but especially not with a dog showing aggression toward a human for an unknown reason).

    This web site has trainers--not sure that it includes behavioralists as well, but it might be worth a look: http://www.trulydogfriendly.com/blog/?page_id=4
  • When he would nip at us or growl at our son, we wouldn't yell, but would talk to him in a tone of voice that would let him know we didn't approve, and would put him outside without us for a "time out."
  • In addition to everything @shibamistress said, have you spoken with the breeder? S/he may have additional insight from knowing the lines, I'm sure would want to know there is an issue, and should be helping you through this.
  • We would never be able to punish him with any kind of physical punishment. Neither of us would ever be able to harm any animal in that way and despise people we know who have. We love Haru and don't want to resort to letting him go, because he has especially taken to Cindy like no other, and he's her baby. It seems like maybe a jealousy issue. We have no trainers or behavior specialists in our area, and I know he won't do well anywhere without his Mom (Cindy). I hope we can find a way through this
  • I've had a hard time reaching the breeder, but am trying.
  • If he was only 5 months old, that's still very young and is it possible he could have been playing too roughly, or jumping to grab food out of the air? I also suggest consulting a behaviorist.
  • edited December 2012
    @Shibamistress - I was under the impression that Behaviorists will follow the scientific method while training so there aren't as many 'variations in style' as there are with trainers. :o

    @Vance - I'm so sorry to hear about what happened! I can appreciate that this is a very trying time for your family and I hope your son is feeling well. :( The vet may be able to refer you to a behaviorist or trainer who will be able to help you with Haru. Also, courts keep a list of trainers equipped to deal with bite/aggression cases. I'm not sure if this list is public, but it might be worth looking into. Some trainers WILL be equipped to help with a bite case, you don't always have to go to a behaviorist - but if you go the trainer route, always research your trainer and ask them many, many questions. If you do not feel comfortable with.them or how they treat you, your family or your dog, bail!
  • For now, keep everyone safe. Willie and Haru should not be together unsupervised. In fact, let Haru drag a leash and only allow him in the same room as Willie when you are both home. Get some baby gates etc, to achieve separation without isolation.

    Below are links to Certified Applied Animal Behaviorists across the country who offer telephone consultations for pet behavior problems (listed in alphabetical order). Or find a Certified Applied Animal Behaviorist near you from the Animal Behavior Society’s CAAB Directory (make link http://www.animalbehavior.org/ABSAppliedBehavior/caab-directory). Some CAABs and ACAAB also offer telephone consultations.

    Debra Forthman, PhD, CAAB, dforthman@mypetsbehavior.com
    (678) 391-0326

    Jill Goldman, Ph.D., CAAB, carletonplace@earthlink.net
    Carleton’s Place: Animal Behavior Services
    (949) 683-4886

    Lori Holmberg, MA, ACAAB, CPDT, lori_holmberg@hotmail.com
    Animal Expressions
    ( 303)400-0740 or (720)327-5335

    Melissa Shyan-Norwalt, PhD, CAAB, mshyan@earthlink.net
    Companion Animal Problem Solvers,Inc.
    http://home.earthlink.net/~companion-animal-problem-solvers/
    (317) 496-7502

    Nancy Williams, MA, RVT, ACAAB, Nancy@DogsWithIssues.com
    www.DogsWithIssues.com
    (410) 374-1556

    You should also know that the field of dog training and pet behavior consulting are not regulated by any government entity. Consequently, anyone can use any professional title they choose (however veterinarians can use the term “behavior specialist only if they are board certified).

    I used to refer clients to Nancy Williams, so I can personally recommend her.

    Good luck. He's a young dog and you should be able to get back on track.
  • Thank you so much. I'll contact her.
  • You may also want to take him to a vet to rule out any medical problems that could cause this.

    I'm curious, did h break the skin when he bit Willie?
  • edited December 2012
    @Vance,

    Here is a suggestion that might not solve it, but it might help:

    I think that Haru is challenging your son's spot in the hierarchy of the pack. The pack's hierarchy is established and maintained during feeding time. You see this in pack animals all the time: Alpha's eat first, then everyone else.
    Akita's are very pack driven. So don't feed Haru at the same time your family is eating, feed him after everyone is done eating.
    Haru has to know that he's not in a position to 'challenge' his pack leaders, this might stop his aggression a bit.
  • @Calia He didn't break the skin when he bit Willie either time, but caused bruising. He is very strong and can bite much harder if he wanted to. I haven't heard him, but my wife said when he did it he sounded very scary.

    @MapleTwinkie We agree with you and now our son is feeding him after he eats. From now on we will have only our son feed him and see how it goes. Thanks.
  • Haru is to be neutered next week. I hope this helps
  • Please please don't use alpha nonsense with your Akita. There is an actual science to animal behavior and studying that will serve you so much better in the long run than relying on alpha hype and hierarchy pseudo science to explain things your dog does.
  • edited December 2012
    @lindsayt - I agree that dog behaviour goes beyond a simple alpha heirarchy explanation and that an owner should explore all those possibilities. I would guess that dog behaviour is influenced by a number of things; environmental, social, situational and gentic factors.

    Pack animal heirarchal social behaviour evolved over tens of thousands of years and is a genetic behavioural characteristic of canines. Fundamentally, our canines are pack animals, some more than others, but especially our Spitz breeds.

    So to dismiss pack-hierachal social behaviour as "nonsense", "alpha hype" and "heirarchal pseudo-science" is probably not accurate.

    Please don't get this confused with a Dominance approach to dog discipline as this is not what i'm advocating and a lot of people seem to link the two. There are ways to establish a heirarchy in a family (pack) without "aggressive" dominant reinforcement behaviours.

    I hope that clarifies my position. :)
  • Japanese Akitas and kids is always a hit or miss situation. I've owned Kaede for four years now and I always keep an eye on her when kids are present.

    Part of the problem is the age of Haru and your son is 6 years old. Although fixing the dog might help your issue it isn't going to solve it. These dogs need time to mature and to them a 6 year old child can be scary and unpredictable.

    MY HUNTCH IS YOUR ISSUE IS RIGHT HERE: 1) "son was eating supper, and my wife Cindy, who was out of the room at the time" 2) "because he has especially taken to Cindy like no other, and he's her baby. It seems like maybe a jealousy issue" 3) "I'm away at work right now, and she called me today and told me that our son was watching TV, and Haru did the same thing again"

    I've seen it happen first hand with a club member and her dog. He is her baby and when she would pickup another puppy, he would go NUTS. Look at your quotes, I see a pattern of Haru bonding with the opposite sex (very common), having to share time with the little one of the same sex. Lastly Haru's issues happen when you wife is out of the room and/or you are not home.

    I agree with the others, since Haru has bitten your son, I would seek professional help. I would also get him a crate in the house for him to call his own. Lastly makes sure the two are not unsupervised at all.
  • edited December 2012
    Dogs are smart creatures. They understand humans are not dogs, do not communicate like dogs, and do not follow the same social rules as dogs. Humans (and other animals) are not a part of the dog's "pack" IMO. A pack is a very specific canine-only relationship, and it is not created simply by multiple dogs living in a household together. Its a working unit and a team.
  • There is a huge variation in behavioralists, unfortunately, just as there is a huge variety of trainers, and because there is no set liscensing, anyone can call themselves a behavioralist, so just like looking for a trainer, a person must be very careful.

    Case in point: the first "behavioralist" I contacted believed all that pack order nonsense (which is, in fact, part of the dominance theory, and is not accurate. Dogs don't even form packs in the way wolves do and the whole thing about pack order even in wolves is much more complex and flexible than rigid. For more info. on this read some of the threads here on canine "dominance" if you want to know more about why this whole idea is problematic.)

    Anyway, I was too inexperienced to know. This so called behavioralist charged me a lot of money to tell me a lot of bullshit about I needed to not let my Shibas on the furniture, etc, and then said I should let them "fight it out" to establish pack order. I knew better than that, thankfully. I later learned, from my vet, that at least two dogs had died under the guidance of this person--in one case she told a family to let her dogs establish the pack order, and two younger dogs killed the elderly GSD.

    That's a cautionary tale: be very careful about finding out exactly what training a person has and what their approaches will be before you hire them, and if they start talking about pack order and dominance or alpha, then do NOT hire them. They will not help.

    My other behavioralist was very very good indeed, and, among other things, is also a teacher of the Karen Pryor clicker trainers. I'd recommend her, but she's in NM.

    Good points from Sean--crate Haru when you can't supervise him. Get professional help, and never let the dog be with the child unsupervised again. And finally, neutering will not fix the problem. It may (or may not) change his temperament slightly, but it will not fix it.)
  • I am so sorry you are having to go through this. A dog biting a child is always a serious issue, but that doesn't mean that you have to get rid of Haru, you have some options.

    Everyone else has already beaten me to all the good points, which is this:
    -Get a behavioralist. Now.
    -Practice positive reinforcement
    -Dogs don't consider humans part of our pack, they're smarter than that
    -Don't submit to the alpha and/or dominance theory.
    -Crate him when there is no supervision. You should never trust a child with a dog, just as you should never trust a dog with a child. It goes both ways...
    -neutering is not going to help. not much anyway. (though, you should still neuter him if you're not going to breed him, I commend you on this effort)



    Didn't I read on another threat that Haru was food possessive? I would try to address that issue too. You can't just throw him in the backyard to eat... That is just putting a bandaid on the problem, not actually solving it. I think addressing this issue will help you trust him more.

    Not that Haru hates children, but try to imagine his viewpoint. Children are weird little humans who move funny, make weird noises, and are at eye level. (eye level can equate to confrontation). I'm not trying to right what Haru did, but try to provide some insight that might be useful in figuring out how to handle this situation,

  • You mentioned having a hard time getting ahold of the breeder.... May I ask who you got him from?
  • All of the other suggestions are great and is what I would have said, too. One thing that has not been said (and I feel is important) is:
    You said you are going to have your 6 year old son feed him from now on.... While I see where you're headed with that and can understand why you would want to do that- I do see it as potentially problematic. My concern is that 1)your son is 6 and still a small child 2) Haru is already 'jealous' of your son 3) he has already bitten your son- twice 4) A lot of dogs tend to be uncomfortable or scared of children. Kids are unpredictable, quick, noisy, etc. (Not an insult to any child of course! It is just how they are lol)
    If your son is feeding him and Haru sees him with his food/food bowl will he react negatively? Possibly.
    If your son stumbles and spills the food then gets down on the floor to pick it up will Haru possibly see this as your son taking his food and react negatively? Possibly. And I can think of many other scenarios.............. Letting a small child feed him is not something I would do because you do not want to set either of them up to fail (and you do not want anyone to get hurt)... I would contact a behaviorist immediately and seek guidance. You can regain harmony in your home... it will just take time and a lot of work.

    If you wanted to let your son do something food related maybe let your son drop treats around Haru when Haru is being nice and calm when your son is present?

    Just my thoughts.
  • I totally think its a bit of jealousy mixed with resource guarding, if you did say he had issues with that too. I got bit by my exs dog... It started like that little nips here and there when he was out of the room. Then his dog got braver and started doing it when he was in the room. We tried working on it ourselves because having a behaviorist come really wasnt an option. Eventually he bit and left a 3 in hole and a 2 in hole(deep) in my right leg. It was bad enough they put a few loose stitches in my leg so it could still drain.

    His dog also started guarding the hallways so i couldnt even walk down the hall... So dont let your son have to walk by him in a hall either.

    No idea how the dog is now we broke up on a bad note and i havent looked back.
  • @jellyfart , he had mentioned in another thread that he got the dog from www.akitainu.ca
  • I'd like to thank you all for your input on my situation. I know Haru is still a pup and I wish I could get inside his head and figure out what's bothering him. I've spoke with several people who claim to know a lot about dog behavior, and have gotten mixed replies. It's hard to know what to do at this point, and we're very distressed. I know that when I get home from work on Thursday Haru will be so excited that he will pee all over me(like he usually does). We're going to do what we can and work with him for a while because we love him. I hope we can get it straightened out.
  • @Kuma123 What you said has been on my mind also about the feeding thing, and it will all be strictly supervised by us.
  • edited December 2012
    I had a somewhat similar story with my Shiba. I rescued him before the owners brought him to the pound because he bit the owners. I figured I could allocate the money I would have paid at the breeders to a behaviorist.

    We hired a behaviorist who came into our homes and worked with us. We found he had triggers that we had to try and avoid to do. Any signs of resource guarding was what we tried to avoid. What we did was take everything away and slowly reintroduced it to him little by little as he began behaving nicer. Our training model was based off of Ruff Love by Susan Garrett. I got to a point where I was able to pet him while he was eating, but his other behaviors still needed work.

    It worked off and on for about three years but he relapsed and I had the help of a vet/behaviorist and we tried meds. It calmed him down immensely but he relapsed again and bit 4 family members. I then had blood tests and additional tests done but we discovered he had a hormone imbalance that caused his bipolar behavior.
  • It is really tough with dogs and kids. I feel your pain. But above anything else, please keep your child safe and do not allow Haru to practice this behavior. The more he practices it the more he will do it. Biting a child is not an acceptable behavior no matter the reason behind it.

    I would keep your dog away from your child until you can have a vet behaviourist evaluate him.
  • Solve it now. both of my dogs are really good with my nephews. but still They are not human and I don't let my dogs play with my nephews without me.

    It's nothing about I trust my dog or not but I just don't do it because anything can happen.

  • edited December 2012
    @vance, I understand your desire to do it but even under close supervision it can go bad very quickly and all you will be able to do is say "I saw it happen" because kids and dogs are so fast that a bite can happen in the blink of an eye and you would have no chance to stop it. It is safer for your son AND Haru to prevent this all together by not having him feed Haru or even interact with him at this point until you can seek help to resolve this. Having fostered numerous dogs with bite histories I can tell you first hand that it happens so fast and sometimes with no warning and then you have an even bigger problem.... and Haru's future with your family is at stake here and your son's safety so it is best to not risk it. This is just my opinion and I hope it helps.....

    *EDIT:
    I agree with the crate suggestion. If you cannot watch him- crate him. If there is a lot going on in the house and he is stressing- crate him. If your son is running around all energetic (normal 6 year old stuff)- crate him and so on. Make the crate a positive thing. A place he can go to have chewies or just to chill....
Sign In or Register to comment.